Mormon was not ambiguous nor concealing information of this landing when he openly stated: “and they were spread through the wilderness on the west, in the land of Nephi; yea, and also on the west of the land of Zarahemla, in the borders by the seashore, and on the west in the land of Nephi, in the place of their fathers' first inheritance, and thus bordering along by the seashore” (Alma 22:28, emphasis added).
Despite this authoritative and dependable statement, Heartland enthusiast and North America theorist Jonathan Neville, states in a lengthy article entitled “Why Apalachicola, Florida, is plausible for the land of Lehi’s landing,” then gives the reference (1 Nephi 18:23-25), which has nothing to do with location but of what Nephi found on the land initially seen and settled. Interesting that he ignores the more defining statement in Alma 22:28.
Jonathan Neville states that Lehi landed at Apalachicola along the south coast of the Florida
panhandle
It certainly would not have made sense to Mormon.
Traveling north by
river 385 miles to Chattanooga, Tennessee, where it is claimed Nephi founded
the city of Nephi
First of all, Tallahassee is 22 miles from the Gulf (south), 168 miles to the Atlantic Ocean (east), and with no sea to the west until the Pacific Ocean (2200 miles away). Consequently, how could Tallahassee be the Land of First Inheritance since it is not located anywhere near a seashore.
In another misuse of scriptural description, Neville states: “The Land in Tennessee is higher in elevation than Zarahemla (Montrose, Iowa) and that is why in the scriptures you will always hear of Nephites traveling “up to” the Land of Nephi and “down to” Zarahemla, as it is a reference to elevation not direction.
City of Nephi to the City of Zarahemla
Hardly something that would be singled out when such a difference would be hard to detect at all.
On the other hand, the distance between Salt Lake City and Park City, is 92.4 feet per mile. Now that is an elevation difference that would be recognized.
Another example would be that between Cuzco (city of Nephi) and Pachacamac (city of Zarahemla) is 10.6 feet per mile. Thus, we can see that the idea of someone traveling from Chattanooga, Tennessee, to Montrose, Iowa, would hardly be described as “going up to” or “going down to,” etc.
The original people who settled the Apalachicolan area, lived in wigwams, or cabins built of bark which are made round, like an oven, to prevent any damage by hard gales of wind. They make the fire in the middle of the house and have a hole at the top of the roof right above the fire, to let out the smoke. These dwellings are as hot as stoves, where the Indians sleep and sweat all night (John R. Swanton, The Indians of the Southeastern United States, Bulletin 137, Bureau of American Ethnology, Government Printing Office, Smithsonian Institution, 1946
Chattanooga, Tennessee, a flat land
on limestone, sandstone, and shales on a parallel line with older rocks along a
level, flat plain. Lookout Mountain can be seen in the distance
Chattanooga rests on a peneplain that is notable for its extent
and degree of perfection on a more or less level land surface produced by
erosion over a long period, undisturbed by crustal movement. The onlap
of this area of successively wedge-shaped younger rock strata extending
progressively further across an erosion surface cut in older rocks. It is
generally associated with a marine transgression in which the younger beds
overlap onto successively older beds along a flat plain, which was reduced anciently to an almost featureless
plain barely above sea level (John B. Reeside, Jr. and William A. Cobban, Studies
of the Mowry Shale Contemporary Formations in the U.S., United States Department of the Interior, U.S. Government Printing Office,
Washington FC, 1960, pp12-13).
Long before the Cherokee and Creek
Indians or early settlers inhabited the Chattanooga area along the bend of the
Tennessee River, it was home to an ancient people, called the Mound builders. Since
destroyed, at least four distinct mounds filled the valley which now is home to
the city of Chattanooga.
Both the city of Chattanooga and all the surrounding land around it for
miles and miles, is part of the flat Cumberland Plateau
Thus, there is no chance one could “go up” to Chattanooga from Montrose (claimed City of Nephi to Zarahemla). In fact the name Lookout Mountain was given this ridge because one can see from the Rock City Point (Point Lookout) into seven states over the extremely flat ground of the Cumberland plateau that surrounds the city (Tennessee, Kentucky, Virginia, North Carolina,s South Carolina, Georgia and Alabama).
Archaeologists have found no evidence that anyone no one anciently had ever lived on or occupied this ridge, and the rest of the area is flat lands, having no place where Ammon could have come upon a hill and looked down on the Land of Shilom and the City of Nephi.
No comments:
Post a Comment