5. Lack of Civilization
The evidence of the type of high civilization described in the Book of Mormon is less prevalent than in Mesoamerica.
The Mayan ruins of Sayil in northern
Yucatan—nothing like it in all of North America
North America: The most advanced native-American people in all of North America are considered to have been the Iroquois, who were known collectively during the colonial years to the French as the Iroquois League and later the Iroquois Confederacy; to the English as the Five Nations, comprising the Mohawk, Onondaga, Oneida, Cayuga, and Seneca (after 1722 when the Tuscarora joined the confederacy, as the Six Nations)—believed by most professionals as being the most developed and progressive of all tribes or groups in North America. A matrilineal society, each clan was linked by a common female ancestor with women possessing a leadership role with in the clan, with the number of clans varying among the nations with the Mohawk only having three to the Oneida having eight.
The Iroquois built and lived in houses made of tree branches and bark, and were called longhouses. In fact, the Iroquois people called themselves Haudenosaunee (Ho-dé-no-sau-nee), meaning “People of the Longhouse.” These houses, varying in length from 15 to 150 feet in length and 15 to 25 feet in width, were clustered in large villages, scattered throughout their territory, with each nation having one to four villages at any one time. Generally, they moved their villages every five to twenty years depending on the depletion of the soil for planting and firewood. These villages were surrounded by a palisade and usually located in a defensible area such as a hill, with access to water.
Top: A typical Iroquois Longhouse—Bottom: a typical
settlement in Andean South America dating long before the Iroquois. Note the difference
between stone houses and those of North America
Since Iroguois history was known only from oral traditions, it is believed they were first established in 1142 after a solar eclipse brought different indigenous groups together (Barbara A. Mann and Jerry L. Fields. "A Sign in the Sky: Dating the League of the Haudenosaunee," American Indian Culture and Research Journal, vol.21, no.2, 1997, pp105-163). Most archaeologists and anthropologists believe that the actual Iroquois League was established in 1450 when five groups or tribes/clans joined forces who emerged just south of the Great Lakes, though some argue for an earlier date of formation, that of 1142, but others maintain they were single indigenous tribes earlier, and not organized into a single confederacy until the 15th century.
The point of this being that the comparison between the most advanced indigenous people in North America, were far inferior in development, achievement, arts, textiles, weaponry, and organization than that of the Aztec and Maya, and especially that of the Inca, by the time the Spanish invaded and the Europeans arrived.
Machu Picchu built high on a mountain
overlooking the Canyons below
There seems little question that the development and level of achievement of the cultures in North America were far inferior to that of Mesoamerica, which itself, did not equal that of Andean South America. It should also be noted that when Lehi left Jerusalem, all four of his sons were grown men and adults, with Nephi the youngest in his late teens or young adult years. The civilization in which they grew up was indeed one of the most advanced in Europe and Asia, with Solomon’s Temple structure drawing people from around the known world to view it.
More than three hundred years before Lehi left Jerusalem, Solomon expanded the confines of the city northward to include the Temple Mount. This more than tripled the size of the original City of David, with the expansion taken up with the Temple and royal buildings. More people came to reside in the city as a consequence of their official and religious capacities, while others came to seek a livelihood in its developing economy, increasing the number to somewhere between 2,000 and 5,000 occupants.
A hundred years later, the area usually referred to as the Western Hill was added to the city of Jerusalem, almost tripling its size, with the populating increasing proportionately. By 721 BC, the populating increased dramatically due to the influx of refugees from the north after the Assyrian conquest of the northern kingdom of Israel. 100 year before Lehi left, the city covered 160 acres, with settlement also extending northward outside the city walls, expanding to a population of 8,000.
Today’s 40-foot high wall around Jerusalem; this wall was 26-feet high
at the time Lehi left Jerusalem
After all, Nephi himself built a large, sea-going, deep-water ship, capable of carrying 50 to 70 people across thousands of miles of open ocean. In addition, Nephi taught his people within a decade of landing in the Land of Promise how to “build buildings, and to work in all manner of wood, and of iron, and of copper, and of brass, and of steel, and of gold, and of silver, and of precious ores, which were in great abundance” (2 Nephi 5:15).
Would such a man that had worked timbers after the manner the Lord showed him have stooped to show his people how to use twigs and branches and grass to make a rickety hut in which to live as found anciently in North America?
Reason suggest otherwise.
No comments:
Post a Comment