Tuesday, May 28, 2019

Let’s End This Silly Idea of Lehi Rounding Africa and into the Atlantic Ocean – Part II

Continued for the last post, regarding the dogged insistence by Heartland and North America theorists to insist that Lehi sailed around Africa.
    When it comes to claiming Lehi sailed around Africa—crossing through the sea of storms that was the graveyard of more than 3000 ships, and the area of the worst sailing weather known with its constant storms, cross-winds, and converging currents—Heartland theorists are completely unrealistic.
    Obviously, Nephi and his brothers would have had extreme difficulty because of their novice knowledge of sailing, to have made such a voyage. In fact, this course around Africa was so dangerous, and such a scourge to Portuguese mariners in the 1400s, that Luís de Camões, the national poet of Portugal and the Portuguese language's greatest poet, penned an epic poem, Os Lusiadas (The Lusiad or Discovery of India), first printed in 1572, when he wrote about the Flying Dutchman, a sailing ship crewed by tormented and damned ghostly sailors who were doomed forever to beat their way through the adjacent waters without ever succeeding in rounding the headland of the Cape because of the threatening storms.
The Cape’s storm clouds, represented by "Adamastor," the Spirit of the Cape, the hideous phantom of unearthly pallor, was known in every maritime port along the Atlantic and Indian Ocean coasts, and became a symbol of the forces of nature Portuguese sailors had to overcome when trying to round the Cape of Storms. These infamously dangerous waters increased in such notoriety and fear that in the 1865 opera L’Africaine about Vasco da Gama trying to round the Cape, the Gerkan opera composer Giacomo Meyerbeer has the slave Nelusko sing a song about Adamastor while he deliberately steers the ship into a storm and it sinks.
    Adamaster became well known as the scary mythical figure who resided in the Indian Ocean, and made life very difficult for the sailors who dared enter his realms by going around the Cape of Storms. This giant was an inspiration for Portuguese authors who wrote about him in their works. To our beloved poet, the meeting with this gigantic force of nature represented the Portuguese ability to overcome fear and conquer the unknown, no matter how dangerous and intimidating.
    The point is, the dangers were, and still are, extreme where the warm, swift, and strong traveling Agulhas Current reaches its termination between two subtropical gyres, creating unusual conditions for inter-ocean exchanges of water kinematic masses and kinetic energy between them, the latter being the highest fluctuating current in the Southern Ocean, creating huge mesoscale eddies.
    At the same time, the cold Benguela Current moving up from the south collides with the Agulhas Current, forcing the latter’s retroflection (turning back on itself). This current has a transport of 100 Sverdrups (1 Sverdrup is equivalent to 1 million cubic metres per second, which is 264,000,000 U.S. Gallons), and more than twice that of the Kuroshio Current—it travels at such speed, the momentum of the current overcomes the vorticity balance holding it to the topography and the current leaves the shelf.
    By comparison the Indian-Pacific Ocean throughfare is 12 Sv, Humboldt (Peruvisn) Current is 18 Sv, Benguela Current 18 Sv, Gulf Stream is 32 Sv, Kuroshio Current 48 Sv, Antarctic Circumpolar Current (Southern Ocean) 125 Sv, reaching 135 Sv through the Drake Passage, and the Florida Current at 150 Sv.

Yellow Circle: The Retroflection where the Agulhas Current is turned back on itself, forming the Recirculation Region, counter currents, eddies, and the Agulhas Ring, all of which creates the tempestuous weather found there
The area of the yellow circler above, just off the southern coast of Africa, where the Agulhas Current hits the rising Buguela Current and reflects back on itself, leads to very high evaporation rates. Here, such high latent heat fluxes lead to increased low-level advection of moisture onshore and local intensification of storm systems.
    The Agulhas Current Air Sea Exchange Experiment, which showed that about 5 times as much water vapor is transferred to the atmosphere above the 50 to 62-mile-wide core of the current, far more than neighboring waters. Using NCEP reanalyses, Meteosat, and Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission data, along with local station and radiosonde observations, continually measure this area.
   Here heavy rainfall occurs in two widely separated locations, along with tornadoes when the moisture flux transects through the storm region and backward trajectories of air parcels create low-level onshore flow of moisture from the Agulhas Current region, which plays a significant role in the storm evolution.
The route of Pedro Álvares Cabral in 1500 AD, from Lisbon, Portugal, to Calicut, India and back. He left with 13 ships and returned with four

Again, the point of this is to show that while Portuguese sailing ships found their way around the African cape, it took many years and the loss of many ships—it was and still is a dangerous route, especially for sailing ships dependent upon the wind and currents. As an example Pedro Álvares Cabral, a Portuguese nobleman, explorer and navigator, and the first European to see Brazil, was sent on an expedition to India by King Manuel I of Portugal. He left with 13 ships on March 9, 1500, following the route of Vasco da Gama, and sighted the land now called Brazil on April 22, 1500, claiming it for Portugal and naming it the "Island of the True Cross." King Manuel renamed this land Holy Cross, but it was later renamed Brazil, after a type of dyewood called pau-brasil found there.
    Cabral stayed in Brazil for 10 days and then continued on his way to India—a trip, fraught with untold dangers, including unbelievable storms, and numerous shipwrecks (at the Cape of Good Hope) that saw him lose coming and going around the Cape nine of his 13 ships. In addition, fifty of his men were killed during an attack from Muslim traders in Calicut, India, who did not want competition on their spice routes.
    However, even if Lehi had gone this way, he would not have landed on the west coast of the Americas, which is where Mormon said he landed (Land of First Inheritance), which should eliminate this route entirely from consideration.
    Yet, it does not. The Heartland theorists continue to cling to this almost impossible feat by Nephi and his brothers, none of which had ever been to sea, nor know anything about sailing, yet are expected to have negotiated a route through some of the most dangerous waters on the planet as though they were long-time mariners with such necessary experience. But they were not. Few members of the House of Israel, at any time, were involved in matters of the Sea. Even at the time of Christ, fishermen were on the Sea of Galilee (a large lake in northern Israel), but not the Mediterranean Sea.
(See the next post, “Let’s End This Silly Idea of Lehi Rounding Africa and into the Atlantic Ocean – Part III,” regarding the dogged insistence by Heartland and North America theorists to insist that Lehi sailed around Africa)

7 comments:

  1. I have been reading this blog for 7 years and it floors me that more people have not found it yet.

    Because of the way Del has presented his consistant well structured information for almost a decade. Someday this knowledge will become mainstream and I bet be the source of the geographical enlightenment of the church.
    It might be 1yr or 50 but it will happen.

    Del thank you for providing so much information and well thought out research. Your blog has brought me so much joy and happiness as a compliment to my study of the Book of Mormon.
    Please dont ever stop posting.
    JA in AGGIE Nation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Del,

    You have done a lot of interesting research for many years. However, I must comment on your disbelief about sailing around Africa to America, the Promised Land and Land of Inheritance for the seed of Joseph--the greatest country in the world--The United States of America. Here is how Nephi described this experience. The fierce storm is very likely the extremely rough waters where the Atlantic and Indian Oceans meet about 90 miles to the east-southeast of the Cape of Good Hope.

    1 Nephi 18:
    14 And on the fourth day, which we had been driven back, the tempest began to be exceedingly sore.
    15 And it came to pass that we were about to be swallowed up in the depths of the sea. And after we had been driven back upon the waters for the space of four days, my brethren began to see that the judgments of God were upon them, and that they must perish save that they should repent of their iniquities; wherefore, they came unto me, and loosed the bands which were upon my wrists, and behold they had swollen exceedingly; and also mine ankles were much swollen, and great was the soreness thereof.
    20 And there was nothing save it were the power of God, which threatened them with destruction, could soften their hearts; wherefore, when they saw that they were about to be swallowed up in the depths of the sea they repented of the thing which they had done, insomuch that they loosed me.
    21 And it came to pass after they had loosed me, behold, I took the compass, and it did work whither I desired it. And it came to pass that I prayed unto the Lord; and after I had prayed the winds did cease, and the storm did cease, and there was a great calm.
    22 And it came to pass that I, Nephi, did guide the ship, that we sailed again towards the promised land.

    God provided the compass (Liahona) and instructions on how to build the ship so it was not destined to failure! Don't try to put limits on God.

    About 2009, Philip Beale sailed around Africa counterclockwise from the eastern Mediterranean. His description of what happened going around the southern tip of Africa is very similar to Nephi's description. In Sep 2019, he plans to sail from Tunisia to America. I heard his lecture several months ago and he passed around a sample of the wood and sail used to build the ship (using 600 BC tools and building methods and wood that was available in the Lebanon and Syria area). Look at https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/9434701/British-adventurers-plan-to-sail-replica-of-Phoenician-sailing-boat-across-Atlantic.html

    Here is what Elder Nelson said at a BYU Devotional on 22 Nov 1988. See his talk entitled, “Thanks for the Covenant” at
    https://speeches.byu.edu/talks/russell-m-nelson_thanks-covenant/.

    “Now, what of the promise of possession of certain lands? Territorial inheritance destined for the sons of Israel provided property in the Holy Land for Reuben, Simeon, Judah, Issachar, Zebulun, Gad, Asher, Dan, Naphtali, and Benjamin.

    But where was the inheritance for Joseph? From the Book of Mormon we learn that his inheritance was this land in the American hemisphere (see Ether 13:8)—identified as being choice above all other lands (see Ether 1:42, 10:28, 13:2; D&C 38:20). It was choice, but not necessarily from the standpoint of scenery or wealth. It was choice because it was chosen. America was to serve as the repository of sacred records written on metallic plates. It one day was to become the location for the restoration of the gospel. It was to host headquarters of the Lord’s restored church.”

    The Book of Mormon is true! It happened between the Gulf Coast and the Great Lakes area. The evidence is overwhelming! Its all about the water...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

      Delete
  3. Unknown, for many years now Del has systematically shown all of us that the North American model is not consistent in anyway with the Book of Mormon. The evidence is overwhelming against the model in every way possible. Now Del has found your Achilles heel. Nephi and particularly the Jaredites could not sail or in the case of the Jaredites, drift around the Cape. The evidence is overwhelming that it could not happen. His research and drawings conclusively show that this is the case. A ship driven before the wind is not capable of making the trip.

    You are comparing apples and oranges when you make your claim. You are taking experienced sailors with ships capable of tacking and comparing them to inexperienced sailors with a ship that according to the scriptural record is driven forth before the wind to make your claim. You still have not proven your claim by stating that a ship driven before the wind can make it around the Cape. You magically lift Nephi and Jaredites over this obstacle and place them in North America. The claim is ridiculous and Del has shown conclusive evidence that your claim is preposterous.

    That is only the beginning of your problem. There are so many other problems with the North American model that Del has wrote about over the years that my advice to you is to abandon the model. It doesn’t work and it in no way matches the scriptural record.

    In fact, those who advocate the North American models resort to changing the very definition of words in order to make their model work. The scriptural record is more authoritative than any opinion of any person. You make all of these claims because you believe the opinions of some general authorities takes precedent over the actual scriptures. Opinions are not facts and the facts do not in anyway support your theories.

    I want to thank Del for your excellent work over the years to bring the truth of where the Nephites and Jaredites actually did live to those who are generally interested in the truth. The day will come when all will know the truth of the location. The evidence is overwhelming in favor of the South America model and anybody with the ability to look at the scriptural record and compare it to the models can quickly see the errors in the other models.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Unknown.

    Your patriotism is admirable, but does not make the USA into Lehi's Land of Promise. There is very little about the setting as described in the Book of Mormon that matches anywhere in North America.

    I believe is would be a great step in the right direction to honor all of those with Lamanite blood scattered from the furthest reaches of South America, through Central America, into Mesoamerica, and into the North by recognizing their noble heritage. What they built in ancient times still stands and is visited by millions of people a year from around the world who are enchanted and mystified by the skill and majesty that testifies of high culture. The Lamanite decedents will rise again and are learning of their roots while many of us gentiles struggle to overcome our pride.

    The USA is not the only place where Gentiles scattered Lamanites as prophesied. It is not the only land of the free where kings do not rule. And it certainly is not the only place where Lamanite descendants are coming to know the truth of who they are. I met a Peruvian woman many years ago, who with a huge smile and joy in her heart told me, "I am a Lamanite!" And to this day, thirty years later, I don't doubt her.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete

  6. I appreciate your passion unknown. The quote you provided “From the Book of Mormon we learn that his inheritance was this land in the American hemisphere” says “American hemisphere”. It gets not say United States of America or North America. I agree with then Elder Nelson, the American Hemisphere is the land of inheritance (which is not the same thing as the lands where the Book of Mormon events occurred-those lands must be somewhere in the American or Western Hemisphere- but could be any subset land or lands of the Western Hemisphere/land of inheritance )

    Over the last 10-15 years I’ve studied every model about Book of Mormon lands; including studying most Books published on each model -and carefully comparing each to the text of the Book of Mormon. I’ve marked and repeatedly studied over 500 scriptures in the Book of Mormon that give some indication of geography. I’ve studied all 2000 plus of Dels’ post comparing his claims to the Book of Mormon, words of church leaders, books from authors of other theories, and spent hundreds of hours researching internet sites about ocean currents, mountains, archaeology in South America, Central America, and North America, etc etc.

    Literally every single scripture agrees with South America / Andes as the lands of Book of Mormon times. All other models including Mesoamerica, Heartland, and Great Lakes have numerous direct conflicts with the texts of the Book of Mormon and cannot be the Book of Mormon lands. Del has painstaking pointed out each of these for the sincere student to read and study for him/herself.

    The doctrine and testimony of the Book of Mormon are what matter most. But for those who already have a testimony and knowledge of the Book of Mormon and are interested in digging deeper into its background including actual lands, Del has done incredible work laying it out. You can study it out carefully and learn for yourself where the Book of Mormon lands are.

    For me, seeing pictures and satellite images on Google earth and other places- of ruins of actual Book of Mormon cities, temples, towers, walls, etc is faith promoting and deepens my understanding and love for the Book of Mormon.

    Best wishes as you continue to study

    ReplyDelete